Hi @shalem120,
Thanks for the detailed information.
I’d like to know how did you start the two flows? I guess that flow Executive summary was set up from SharePoint online, while flow Request Feedback was start from flow.onmicrosoft.com.
Per my test, I found that when using SharePoint document library, start the flow from SharePoint online, you will be able to configure the list as a user, while if you start the flow from flow.onmicrosoft.com, you can’t. However, when using SharePoint list, you can set the list as a user for both situations.
Please recreate the flow from SharePoint online, I assume then you will be able to set it.
Best regards,
Mabel Mao