@mjbaylon
Well, there's something about the data type that PowerApps doesn't like. I just did a quick test using a plain text column using your code and had no issues.
Has the data in the field be copied from somewhere eg the Web or some sort of Datasource? If so, there maybe hidden characters that you cannot see inside the fields causing the issue. You could try
- Add a new column in your Excel file, call it Status_Test
- Then free type a few of the matching values from the Status field into this column - don't copy&Paste
- Then, using ShowColumns on this new column to see if that works
- If it does, this would point towards the data being not 'plain text'
You could also try Refreshing the datasource and/or completely removing it and re-adding it back in.
My money's on the data being off, but let me know.