The Closed date is not required in SP. Here is my Patch formula (I added the If(!IsBlank) on the DateClosed, but didn't make a difference).
ForAll(TrackingCollection,
Patch('Program Tracking',
Defaults('Program Tracking'),
{
Title: LineType,
'AssignedTo-Email': LineAssignedTo,
Description: LineDescription,
'Date Identified': DateValue(LineDateIdentified),
'Date Closed': If(!IsBlank(DateValue(LineDateClosed)), DateValue(LineDateClosed)),
'Tracking Resolution': LineResolution,
Likelihood: LineLikelihood,
Impact: LineImpact,
'Contract Name': LineProgramName,
BU: LineBU,
ProgramID: FormIssues.LastSubmit.ID}));
Navigate(TrackingOverviewScreen,ScreenTransition.Fade)