Hi @tlevine ,
Could you please share more details about the formula you used to initialize the ?
Do you want to set a default value within the ComboBox using a variable?
Based on the error message that you mentioned, it seems to tell that the DefautlSelectedItems property of the ComboBox is required to provide a Table value. Please check if you have set your variable as a Table value rather than a record value or single Text value.
I have made a test on my side, please consider take a try with the following workaround:


The data structure of RecordsCollection as below:

Set the OnSelect property of the "Initialize Var" button to following:
Set(DefaultOption, Table({ProductName: "Power BI"}))
On your side, you should initialize your variable as below:
Set(Var1, Table({DisplayColumn: "Specific Value"}))
Note: The DisplayColumn represents the column you used as display value within your ComboBox.
Please consider take a try with above sample solution, then check if the issue is solved.
Best regards,