Hi @barrymac20 ,
Do you want to decide which image display in the image control based on variable value?
I've made a similar test and not met any problem.
I think your key point should be about component.
Please notice that: since the images are inside component, so only the variables inside the component could affect these image controls.
If you set those variables outside component, the image controls will not affected by these variables.
To solution is to pass these outside variables to component.
1)if these variables are inside the component.
In this situation, you need to create variables by using the controls inside the component.
Just like this:
insert some buttons inside the component, set their OnSelect:
Set(varSection01Image,....)
Set(varSection02Image,....)
....
Then you could directly use these variables in your images.
set the images' Image just like the formula that you used:
Section01Image's Image:
If(varSection01Image=....,....,....)
Section02Image's Image:
If(varSection02Image=....,....,....)
2)If these variables are outside the component.
It means that you use controls outside the component to create these variables.
Then you need to pass these variables to component.
How to pass these variables to component?
Firstly, create 16 custom properties (input) in this component.
Like this:

Then set Section01Image's Image like this:
If(Component1.varSection01Image=....,'xxx',
Component1.varSection01Image=....,'xxx',
....)
//component is this component name
fill in variable value in "..."
fill in image name in "xxx"
set Section02Image's Image like this:
If(Component1.varSection02Image=....,'xxx',
Component1.varSection02Image=....,'xxx',
....)
//component is this component name
fill in variable value in "..."
fill in image name in "xxx"
..... others are similar
Outside the component, in the app insert this componnet.
set the component's varSection01Image:
varSection01Image
//set component's varSection01Image to the variable's value
set the component's varSection02Image:
varSection02Image
..... others are similar
Then images inside the component will change with the variable outside the component.
Best regards,