@RABronn
The DefaultSelectedItems (DSI) of your "not working" control is not correct. It is specifying a record that has a single column called Order, yet your Items property is all columns of the record of your datasource...so it will not match.
I would suggest narrowing the Items to the column that you are specifying in the DSI - DataSource.Order
Or, performing a lookup on the record from your datasource - LookUp(DataSource, Order=Parent.Default)
Otherwise, the DSI and the Items will not match and you will not have results.
I hope this is helpful for you.